Alt text: a man and a woman writing on a white board
Title: Startup Selection Criteria

Meta Description: Explore NBER’s research on venture capital practices and the critical startup selection criteria used to identify promising startups. Learn how these insights shape successful investment strategies.

Introduction

Venture capital (VC) plays a pivotal role in fostering innovation and driving the growth of startups worldwide. Understanding the startup selection criteria employed by VCs is essential for entrepreneurs seeking investment and for investors aiming to identify high-potential ventures. The National Bureau of Economic Research (NBER) provides comprehensive insights into these selection processes, shedding light on what makes a startup attractive to venture capitalists.

NBER’s Comprehensive Research on Venture Capital

In their 2025 working paper, Young Soo Jang and Steven N. Kaplan delve into the intricate dynamics of venture capital selection. Analyzing over 8,000 sourced deals from an early-stage VC firm, their study reveals that approximately 30% of sourced startups secure at least $1 million in funding from some VC. However, only a fraction of these deals extend beyond initial funding rounds, highlighting the challenges in scaling.

Key Findings

Selection Ability: VCs demonstrate a clear ability to select promising startups, as evidenced by the superior performance of invested deals compared to non-invested ones.
Noisy Selection: Despite this ability, the selection process remains noisy. Only 32% of invested firms raised more than $10 million, and a mere 13% exceeded $25 million in funding.
Evaluation Criteria: The study identifies team, market, product, and exit characteristics as primary evaluation metrics. While the team is crucial for initial funding, market and product factors gain prominence in larger financing rounds and long-term success.

“Consistent with other recent work, this is consistent with VCs overweighting team in their initial investment decision.”
— Young Soo Jang & Steven N. Kaplan, NBER Working Paper 33483

Startup Selection Criteria: What VCs Look For

Understanding the criteria VCs use to evaluate startups can significantly enhance an entrepreneur’s chances of securing funding. Based on NBER’s insights and industry practices, the following factors are paramount:

1. Team

Expertise and Experience: A strong, experienced team with complementary skills is often the first filter.
Leadership: Effective leadership that can navigate challenges and drive the company towards its vision.

2. Market

Market Size: A large and growing market indicates potential for scalability and significant returns.
Market Trends: Alignment with current and future market trends can position a startup for long-term success.

3. Product

Innovation: Unique and innovative products that solve real problems stand out.
Product-Market Fit: Demonstrating that the product meets the needs of the target market is crucial.

4. Exit Potential

Acquisition Prospects: Potential for acquisition by larger firms provides an exit strategy for investors.
IPO Viability: The ability to go public is another key consideration for long-term investment.

The Role of the Global Venture Capital Connector

Addressing the challenges highlighted by NBER, the Global Venture Capital Connector aims to revolutionize the fundraising landscape for startups, especially in emerging markets. By democratizing access to venture capital, this initiative provides startups with the necessary tools and networks to navigate the complex investment ecosystem.

Key Features

Investor Network: Access to a global network of over 50 top venture capitalists.
Advisory Services: Comprehensive support including fundraising strategy structuring, investor deck development, and pitch coaching.
Tailored Support: Customized approaches to enhance startup visibility and attractiveness to investors.

Addressing Market Needs

With the global venture capital market projected to reach $300 billion by 2025, the Global Venture Capital Connector aligns perfectly with market trends. By focusing on emerging markets, this initiative taps into underserved regions, fostering a more inclusive and diverse startup ecosystem.

Opportunities and Challenges

Strengths

Robust Network: Established relationships with leading VCs provide significant exposure for startups.
Comprehensive Services: Tailored advisory services enhance the overall fundraising strategy.

Weaknesses

Market Trust: As a new initiative, building trust and reputation is an ongoing challenge.
Competitive Landscape: Navigating competition from established VC firms and platforms requires strategic positioning.

Opportunities

Democratization Trend: Increasing demand for inclusive venture financing practices presents a significant growth opportunity.
Emerging Markets: Rising startup activity in regions like Asia and Africa offers untapped potential.

Threats

Established Competitors: Existing platforms with established credibility pose a threat to new entrants.
Market Dynamics: Rapid changes in market trends require continuous adaptability and innovation.

Conclusion

NBER’s insights into venture capital and startup selection criteria provide valuable guidance for both investors and entrepreneurs. By understanding the key factors that drive successful investments, startups can better position themselves to secure funding and thrive in competitive markets. Initiatives like the Global Venture Capital Connector further enhance these opportunities by democratizing access to venture capital, fostering a more inclusive and dynamic startup ecosystem.

Ready to elevate your startup’s fundraising strategy? Join the Global Venture Capital Connector today and connect with top venture capitalists to unlock your startup’s full potential.